Week 15: Assessment Methods and Evidence

This weeks Lesson can be seen here and a more detailed document of assessment methods can viewed Here.

The lesson started with a bit of fun really, drawing a desert island and then swapping drawings with the peer group and assessing the drawings. It just served to illustrate the assessment didn't have any criteria, any point of reference with which to make an assessment. Therefore, all assessment was subjective. This set the lesson off to a good start. We discussed the importance of clear goals, without which, assessment cannot be constructive, with a view to offering informative and helpful feedback:

Summative Assessment

 Sometimes called Final Assessment, this aims to make a final measure of a students progress. Usually Graded: Eg: 90% or A+. Typically this form of assessment is more for the benefit of a client. For example a prospective employer can easily see what standard of education you have reached/achieved. 10 years down the line, this assessment will likely be far from a true reflection of your sum of knowledge in a given topic.
The aim may be to sum up what the candidate can do (criterion referencing). This might be done with the aid of a checklist of skills or competences, and/or by reports
or profiles. Alternatively, the aim may be to grade candidates, or place them in a
rank order (norm referencing). This is usually done by means of an examination,
designed to differentiate between candidates on the basis of the breadth and depth
of their learning.

Formative Assessment

Formative assessment is informative feedback to learners while they are still
learning the topic. But to be truly formative, this information must be used by the
learner to improve. The teacher can provide the formative assessment, but the
learners can also formatively assess themselves and each other. Research shows
that this feedback while you learn has more effect on student achievement than
any other single factor, so it’s worth getting right! Formative Assessment prepares a student for the Summative or Final Assessment. Eg; Like a Mock exam prepares you for the real thing.  
Geoff Petty. (2009). Assessment. In: Nelson Thornes Teaching Today. Cheltenham: Nelson Thornes. 479.

_____________

The main use of assessment for teachers is the ongoing or formative assessment.
This is used throughout the course to form judgements on whether, and to what
extent, learning has been successful; and to pinpoint difficulties so that remedial
action can be taken. Initial and diagnostic assessment have similar ‘formative’
roles. They are carried out at the beginning of a course.  
Geoff Petty. (2009). Assessment. In: Nelson Thornes Teaching Today. Cheltenham: Nelson Thornes. 479.

Assessment is an essential part of the learning process. It serves several vital roles in an education system, such as:

• informing teacher and learner of progress and future development needs; 

• recognition of achievement; 

• providing accountability data on the performance of teachers, departments, education organisations and even international comparisons.

Both assessment for learning and assessment of learning. Assessment for learning provides information to learners and teachers about the learners’ current levels of ability and this information guides the teaching and learning strategies that are planned and prepared by the teacher. This is known as formative assessment. Assessment of learning provides information of learners’ achievement and is usually summative rather than formative. Both methods have purpose and both recognise learners’ achievement.

Lynn Machin, Duncan Hindmarch, Sandra Murray & Tina Richardson (2013). A Complete Guide to the Level 4 Certificate in Education and Training. Nothwich: Critical Publishing. 59-73.

Norm Referencing:
As in summative assessment of GCSE, provides a graded result, compared to a peer group at a specific time. Yields an estimate of the position of the tested individual in a predefined population, with respect to the trait being measured. The estimate is derived from the analysis of test scores and possibly other relevant data.

Criterion Referencing:
A criterion-referenced test would report the student's performance strictly according to whether the individual student correctly answered set questions. A norm-referenced test would report primarily whether this student correctly answered more questions compared to other students in the group.

Student Referencing:
The advantages of self-directed learning are that it strongly encourages active
learning, develops student autonomy and gives the responsibility for learning to
the student. A self-directed learning approach is widely used when teaching adults,
especially adult professionals, where it underpins the idea of the ‘reflective practitioner’.


Homework:
Prepare a 5 min presentation on assessment and feedback based on your teaching practice: Preparation can be viewed: Here (PDE)